INANE Response The INANE community, representing editors of credible and reputable nursing journals, believes that it is imperative to inform nurses of the harm inherent in this new hazard that has arrived in the publishing scene. We encourage nursing authors to use Beall’s list of predatory publishers at Scholarly Open Access as a reliable resource. Plagiarism in Predatory Publications: A Comparative Study of Three Nursing Journals. ce for practice. Owens JK(1), Nicoll LH(2). Nursing Open, 4, 60. Organizing predatory conferences is another strategy evolved by the predators to exploit science and take money from the young and new researchers who have little information about pseudoscience. VIEW THE NURSING JOURNALS DIRECTORY. Welcome to Predatory Journals Jan 24, 2017. Jeffrey Beall scrubbed his blog and lists of predatory journals and publishers last week after years of running ScholarlyOA. The focus of predatory journals is on attracting authors, who are the primary source of revenue, and deception is common. Articles in predatory journals should not be cited. This research did not receive any specific grant from funding agencies in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors. Beall's list of predatory open access journals: RIP. Predatory journals, characterized by poor editorial practices and questionable peer review, constitute a threat to academic literature. The reviews were classified by topic (clinical practice, education, and management). Citations to predatory journals in reviews of research potentially weaken the strength of these reviews, which are relied upon by nurses as evidence for practice. Nursing Open, 5 (4), 186. Charles Collom, DNP '18, Marilyn Oermann, Thelma M. Ingles Professor of Nursing, and Valerie Sabol, professor, are co-authors of "An Assessment of Predatory Publication Use in Reviews" in the Clinical Nurse Specialist, Vol. Considering 127 predatory journals in the context of 247 legitimate publications suggests that predatory journals are making inroads in the scholarly literature in nursing. Journal of Nursing Scholarship, 48 , 624-632. doi: 10.1111/jnu.12248. Oermann et al. land, Maine, editors of nursing journals agreed that it was important to raise awareness about this phenomenonin our constituent communities. Design: A two-phase approach was used. I often receive emails inviting me to submit papers to what seem to be legitimate journals. Last Updated 2019/02/03. Predatory publishing is a contemporary term that refers to dubious open access publishing where there are questionable practices of marketing, business, and alteration of … However, the seven journals in this current project were in our original study of predatory nursing journals and determined to reflect characteristics of predatory journals (Oermann et al., 2016). Our medical librarian developed a way of searching for the predatory journal title in the reference lists of articles in Scopus. Go to update. The influx of predatory publishing along with the substantial increase in the number of predatory journals pose a risk to scholarly communication [1, 2].Predatory journals often lack an appropriate peer-review process and frequently are not indexed [], yet authors are required to pay an article processing charge.The lack of quality control, the inability to effectively disseminate research … https://doi.org/10.1016/j.outlook.2019.05.001. Predatory journals are new in the nursing literature, with five journals beginning in 2011, six in 2012, nine in 2013, and the majority in 2014 (n = 27, 25.0%) and 2015 (n = 54, 50.0%). There's also evidence that articles from predatory journals are being cited in mainstream journals, including nursing journals. These 7 predatory journals had published the largest number of articles in nursing, and in earlier studies we confirmed that they had questionable peer review and other editorial practices. ScienceDirect ® is a registered trademark of Elsevier B.V. ScienceDirect ® is a registered trademark of Elsevier B.V. They may publish their research, teaching practices, consulting work, leadership lessons, theory development – whatever topic is applicable to their areas of scholarship. The purposes of this study were to assess the (a) extent to which reviews have relied on articles published in predatory journals, (b) nursing research practice areas most reliant on predatory journal citations, and (c) extent to which predatory journal citations are being used in reviews that guide the care of sensitive or vulnerable groups. (2016) found that the largest growth in predatory publishers and journals occurred in 2014 and later, with 140 journals from 75 publishers. (Shen and Bjork) Roughly 15% of articles published in predatory journals are from United States authors. Potential predatory scholarly open-access journals Instructions: simply enter the journal’s name or its URL in the search box above.If the journal has a publisher that was assessed to be predatory, then it is included on the Publishers list. Read this article about predatory publishing and what red flags to look for to ensure the integrity of your professional literature. We use cookies to help provide and enhance our service and tailor content and ads. Second, conclusions about the extent of citations of predatory articles in the nursing literature are limited by our study of only seven journals. Citations of predatory articles transfer the information into scientific literature. © 2019 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. Predatory publishers: Time for action. Welcome to the Directory of Nursing Journals, a joint service of Nurse Author & Editor and INANE. In the dataset, there were 37 journals with no published articles. All journals published by a predatory publisher are potentially predatory unless stated otherwise. In a subsequent 2018 study in Nursing Outlook that evaluated the quality of the articles published in predatory journals, Oermann and colleagues found that 96.3% of the 358 articles assessed were rated poor or average. Study of Predatory Open Access Nursing Journals. The term “predatory journals” was coined less than a decade ago by then-University of Colorado librarian Jeffrey Beall, who has worked extensively to track suspicious journals. Predatory nursing journals continue to persist, yet fewer may now be in existence. 4, July/August 2020. However, further inspection may reveal otherwise. Copyright © 2020 Elsevier B.V. or its licensors or contributors. Literature and other types of reviews with 1 or more citations to a predatory journal (n = 78) were assessed. Awareness of predatory publishers and their practices is now much higher than even three years ago: predatory being defined by the Oxford English Dictionary as ‘preying naturally on’ and ‘seeking to exploit’ others. Nurse authors, reviewers, and editors must be able to identify predatory articles. Bibliographic information and subsequent citation information were then collected and analyzed. Purpose: This study was undertaken to learn how predatory journal articles were cited in articles published in legitimate (nonpredatory) nursing journals. The purpose of this study was to analyze publication and dissemination patterns of articles published in known predatory nursing journals. [PMC free article] [Google Scholar] Watson R. (2017b). Author information: (1)Rho Nu-at-Large and Delta Xi, Editor-in-Chief, OJIN: The Online Journal of Issues in Nursing, Associate Professor of Nursing, Ashland University, Ashland, OH, USA. The Open Nursing Journal is an Open Access online journal, which publishes research articles, reviews/mini-reviews, letters and guest edited thematic issues in all areas of nursing.. Our initiative “Open Access, Editorial Standards and Predatory Publishing,” launched during the 2014 conference in Portland, Maine is now becoming a significant and visible “presence” in our nursing literature. The journals were identified using Beall's list of predatory standalone journals with “nursing” in the title and reviewing predatory publisher Web sites for nursing journals (Beall, 2017, Oermann et al., 2016). 34, No. Predatory journal articles, which may not have been subjected to an adequate peer review, are being cited in review articles published in legitimate nursing journals, weakening the strength of these reviews as evidence for practice. The Directory of Nursing Journals, a vetted list of scholarly publications in nursing, lists 247 journals. Further analysis indicated that these articles were cited in 141 nonpredatory nursing journals of various types. The fight against fraud continues. The 78 reviews contained 275 citations to articles published in predatory journals; 51 reviews (65%) substantively used these references. One author reported falling prey to a predatory journal and encouraged other authors to check both the journal name and publisher on Beall’s list before submitting an article. Purpose: This study compared three known predatory nursing journals to determine the percentage of content among them that was plagiarized or duplicated. Predatory journal articles were cited in all types of nonpredatory nursing journals. In the years since, such publications have steadily increased, in part because of the growth in open-access journals. At the 2014 annual meeting of the International Academy of Nurse Editors, journal editors agreed to collectively address the issue of predatory journals, especially those in nursing, in order to better inform our authors, readers, and reviewers. By: Maureen Shawn Kennedy, MA, RN, FAAN, Editor-in-Chief, American Journal of Nursing. An earlier study documented the scope of predatory publishing in nursing and described characteristics of 140 predatory nursing journals and authors (Oermann et al., 2016). Oermann et al 7 located a total of 127 predatory nursing journals using Beall’s list. These “fake,” “predatory,” or “pseudo” journals misrepresent their peer-review and publication processes. Why Predatory Journals are Bad for Nurse Authors and Nursing Scholarship If you are a student reading this post, you may not know that academic faculty are expected to publish. Abstract. Citations to predatory journals in reviews of research potentially weaken the strength of these reviews, which are relied upon by nurses as evidence for practice. Some of these practices include: journal names or website designs that can be confused with established journals This is a list of possibly predatory journals.The kernel for this list was extracted from the archive of Beall’s list at web.archive.org.It will be updated as new information or suggested edits are submitted or found by the maintainers of this site. Predatory journals are out to get you and your work. Original list. There were 814 citations to articles published in predatory nursing journals. Copyright © 2020 Duke University School of Nursing, Alum, Faculty Contribute to Article on Predatory Journals' Impact, Health Professions Higher Education Excellence in Diversity (HEED), #9 National Institutes of Health Funding & Research, Accredited Program in Teaching / Education, Promoting Pedagogical Expertise of Faculty, National League for Nursing Center of Excellence in Nursing Education, Advancing the Science of Nursing Education, Enhancing Student Learning and Professional Development, Accelerated Bachelor of Science in Nursing, DNP Executive Leadership Specialty & Certificate, Continuing Education & Specialized Programs, Avenues for Students Wanting to Care for Veterans, DUSON Team Works with Salons to Prevent HIV among Black Women in the U.S. South, Brandon Celebrated for Neonatal Nursing Contributions with Lifetime Achievement Award, Randolph Co-Investigator For Recently Funded PCORI Grant, Pan, Student Tsumura Co-Write Article on COVID U.S. Mortality, Biederman, Colleagues Win IRL Research Brief Award, Certified Healthcare Simulation Educators, Center for Nursing Discovery Advisory Board, Community Health Improvement Partnership Program, Center of Excellence in Nursing Education, Duke Elder Family/Caregiver Training Center, Duke Advancement of Nursing, Center of Excellence, Office of Global and Community Health Initiatives, Office of Diversity, Equity and Inclusion, Duke Health Center for Interprofessional Education and Care, An Assessment of Predatory Publication Use in Reviews. By continuing you agree to the use of cookies. Citations of articles in predatory nursing journals. Beall (2016) found that there were 882 predatory open access journals, and their growth was exponential. Several nursing authors ( Lewinski & Oermann, 2018 ; Power, 2018 ) have highlighted tips to assist in evaluating journals. The extent of citation and citation patterns were studied. Predatory or unethical publishing is typically defined as publishers or journals who have employed deceptive or questionable processes to profit from publishing scholarly works. In other words, this is a problem that needs to be addressed. Here is the list of the predatory conferences that everyone should avoid them. [PMC free article] [Google Scholar] Watson R. (2018). Nursing journals from predatory publication outlets may look authentic and seem to be a credible source of information. The purposes of this study were to assess the (a) extent to which reviews have relied on articles published in predatory journals, (b) nursing research practice areas most reliant on predatory journal citations, and (c) extent to which predatory journal citations are being used in reviews that guide the care of sensitive or vulnerable groups. In addition, predatory journals are often short lived, with new predatory journals appearing on a regular basis, therefore, making it impossible for any list to be comprehensive. The Directory is a joint service of INANE and Nurse Author & Editor, which is Edited by Leslie Nicoll, PhD, MBA, RN, FAAN.. To use the Directory, click on the link to the Nursing Journals Directory wherever you find it. Education and information may help authors and reviewers identify predatory journals, thereby discouraging submissions to these publications and hesitancy among authors to cite articles published in them. Not all of these predatory journals are in biomedicine fields, but biomedicine is a major area for predatory publishers, and the prevalence of predatory journals varies between specific fields. A total of 814 citations of articles published in predatory nursing journals were identified. Using Scopus, reference lists were searched for citations from seven identified predatory nursing journals.